I have never owned one, but I have used a DXR a few times. Nice reel, seemed pretty tough and had a smooth drag. The drag is a combo of cork, metal and rulon...no idea how it holds up over time but the Orvis warranty is pretty good.
I think they are about the same price as a Reddington or Teton now, for comparative shopping purposes. Don't think you can go wrong with any of them.
I've got the DXR anti reverse in a 9/10. I love it (no smashed thumbs). The drag adjustment does have a problem with stripping the threads if you are not careful. Orvis replaced mine for free. As far as I know, the direct drive does not have this problem, and is an excellent reel.
I have fished with an Orvis DXR for the past 3 years. It is an excellent reel with a finish that is hard to match. The first season I had it I lost it overboard in Plymouth attached to a Loomis IMX 9wt. I found it the next morning due to some new moon minus tides and a bit of luck. The finish is still perfect and I do not wash it off consistently after I use it. I have caught quite a few albies on it and the drag works very smooth. The problem with the drag adjustment knob was fixed a long time ago. Orvis re-engineered the part and there aren't problems now. An excellent product but more expensive than some other reels with similar features but it is a finely made reel with uncomparable corrosion resistance..