My wife and I stayed at Pigeon Cay August 2010. It was my wife's first trip to the Bahamas and she loved it. Right on a beautiful beach and she loves beach sitting. She also went into the water which is something she will not do in NC.
I didn't fish all day like I usually do, spending time with her. I did fish most mornings. There is a flat right behind Pigeon Cay that is a 5 minute walk. I caught a few fish there. I fished up at Orange Creek one day. Hit it at low tide and found tailers. Went back into the creek more when the tide got up and found some cruising fish. I should have spent more time there. You would need to rent a car. We rented a truck to explore. Most flies should work there. Can't go wrong with Gotchas. Use something light for tailers.
Last edited by Swalt; 12-30-2011 at 07:33 AM.