RE:SOUTH MONOMOY ISLAND
I'll throw my chip in favor of the NM/SB run over the SI run based on a few factors. 1. I'm pinching pennies, 2. It sounds like NM/SB is more of a "sure" thing, 3. No matter where we go it will be new and an adventure to me though I certainly understand the alure SI holds for those who have done NM/SB before, 4. NM/SB gives me more casting time.
I wasn't going to be doing the SI trip anyway mostly for reasons 1 & 4 so I don't know if my vote should really count. I was a little bummed though that I would miss fishing with most of the "gang" on Saturday.