Fly Fishing Forum

Fly Fishing Forum (http://www.flyfishingforum.com/flytalk4/index.php)
-   Gear Talk - Fly Stuff Spoken Here (http://www.flyfishingforum.com/flytalk4/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   tarpon 140 kayak vs. prowler angler from ocean kayak (http://www.flyfishingforum.com/flytalk4/showthread.php?t=19578)

wind roper 02-12-2005 04:04 PM

tarpon 140 kayak vs. prowler angler from ocean kayak
 
if any one has any feed back on these two kayaks please let us know. it will make things easier for those of us in th market to buy one. the tarpon 140 is 14' long sit on top style with the option of a rudder for $749 and $925 with rudder. the ocean kayak the prowler angler is 15' long for $749 and $1079 with rudder and 6" hatch option. how much of a difference will the rudder make in the ocean and is it worth paying the extra money for that option? is one of these kayaks better than the other? any other recomendations for a kayak in the same price range for flats fishing that is a sit on top style?

fishingbum 02-16-2005 12:51 AM

i think the Prowler will be faster and track better sans rudder by virtue of it's length. they are similar in width, i believe, but the Prowler is a few pounds lighter and can carry more weight. if you're light, you and the boat might not sit at the optimal depth in the water but i hear people don't really notice that problem. molded-in footwells vs. the footbraces in the Tarpon are up to you to pick. i personally like the clean cockpit floor of the Tarpon and had no problems stripping line to and from the floor of that boat; standing should be easier without the molded footbraces. the paddle holders will catch the line if you let it float in the water, tho. likely the same on the Prowler since i think it has even more rigging lines along the sides of the boat. both the Tarpon and Prowler have two open areas for mounting rod holders to the rear of the seat and more in front so rigging won't be an issue. the front hatches on both boats have their drawbacks: the Tarpon, i hear, can leak if turtled, but i can't imagine the boat will flood and sink or anything. the Prowler, on the other hand, has a water-tight neoprene cover under the hard hatch cover but it is HARD to get on. it took me 15 minutes to get it on and i was on the floor of the showroom and not on the water. either way, you can't go too wrong with these yaks. both are good for daylong paddling and will be fast enough unless you're going really, really far. i haven't had a chance to paddle a Prowler yet, but i hear it's very fast and a good fishing boat. the Tarpon i have paddled and i like. stable enough to cast from and land fish from. whichever you pick, get the rudder. currents and wind are a bear to fight in the ocean or open water. plus, when you drift, you can manage better. i'm going to be ordering a Tarpon soon with rudder so i can hit the coast of Texas for trout, reds, etc. have fun!

* don't forget boats like the Ride if you're going to be doing mostly flats and protected water. you CAN stand and cast from it and pole when needed. i've heard of newbies standing in their Rides. it'll be slower than the above two, tho, if you do plan on longer paddling distances to get to the fish.

doogue 02-16-2005 07:22 AM

Go with a rudder
 
My only advice here would be to go with the rudder - no matter which boat you choose.

The rudder does allow you to manage your drifts a bit better and after a long day of paddling and fishing it really does help to keep you from getting blown around.

Then again I am biased because of my float tubing days. When tubing you have your feet to help you position yourself in the right direction when fishing. A rudder gives you just a touch of the same control.

Have fun.

Mike

jmccaff 02-23-2005 10:57 AM

Hobie
 
Before you decide on those two, consider the Hobie Mirage Outback. I had access to one in Ft. Lauderdale for a week and found it to be the best FFishing Kayak i've ever tried. Because the kayak utilizes the pedal driven Mirage drive for propulsion you can always keep one hand on the fly rod.

It came in handy when I was navigating the small canals looking for rolling Tarpon, I could actually move and cast at the same time!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:45 PM.


Copyright Flyfishingforum.com (All Rights Reserved)