Breaking rod in casting? [Archive] - Fly Fishing Forum

: Breaking rod in casting?


fishordie
09-18-2006, 09:19 PM
Hi all, I have a question.

I just broke a Horizon II 8wt near the bottom of the tip section as well as the second section at the border(?) with the tip section. This happened about 50ft of the SA Bonefish taper floating line out of the tip in the forward stroke. The rod was bought new and has been used about 5 times, and has never been hit by a fly. It's been taken care of very well. I noticed that the coating on the snake guide wraps has been scraped and worn to the extent that expose a bit of the thread on one or two of the guides, simply due to friction with the fly line.

Is it my aggressive casting style that resulted in the breakage? But I thought that this rod is designed for people who have aggressive casting styles... Or was this just an isolated incident that occurred by chance (a flaw in the blank to begin with)? I have had several other T&T rods (but no other Horizon) and had never had this problem before. What do you all think about this sort of breakage? Does it happen fairly often?

I would much appreciate your feedback.

Fishordie

dewey
09-18-2006, 09:30 PM
sounds sketchy...
Probably the top section worked loose, and it broke from the impact of the two pieces during casting around the ferrules. As for the guide thing, that just doesn't seem right for a high end line like that.

fishordie
09-18-2006, 10:16 PM
Thanks for your post.

Actually, the ferrule was very tight and didn't play any role in this breakage, I believe. I periodically check all ferrules while fishing and tighten them when necessary, but it's usually those between the butt and the 3rd, and 3rd and 2nd sections that need to be tightened on this rod. The fit between the top and second section of this rod remains very tight for hours and hours. This incident occurred only about an hour and a half into the fishing.

Eddie
09-18-2006, 10:30 PM
this does sound odd. I have never seen or heard of fly line wearing away epoxy.
As for the break, it is possible that there was a defect. I suppose it is possible that damage occured un noticed by you untill the break. I have broked rods "just casting...honest" and I always assumed that there was a flaw either in the manufacter or more likely a small scratch or nick in just the right place.
send it back and for 35 bucks t&t will take care of you.

FredA
09-19-2006, 07:30 AM
I have broken a rod while casting. This occured after having had a weighted fly hit the tip when making a quick cast to breaking fish (wind on my casting arm). Any possibility the tip was scratched in such a manner prior to the fatal cast?

juro
09-19-2006, 07:43 AM
I've seen this before in a couple of cases:

1) when landing a fish and over-flexing the tip (high sticking)

2) when shocking the rod due to off-timing of the stroke with a lot of line out

Since you said 'while casting', 50ft of line in the air and mentioned friction wear and agressive stroke my assumption would be that you would benefit from smoothing out your casting stroke, no offense intended and meant only from a fellow caster / instructor's point of view.

If you have a lot of line out and your stroke gets ahead of itself there can be a tremendous shock applied to the rod while forces are moving in opposite directions.

fishordie
09-19-2006, 04:45 PM
Fred A., Juro,

Thank you for your feedback. I honestly believe that there
was no chance for any prior damage done to the tip section
as I was babying this rod (I've had it for only 2 months).
Of course, I would have not noticed it if I had done some
internal damage that doesn't show any scratch or scrape
on the blank surface... (I had to grip the tip seciton pretty
hard to pull it apart from the second section after fishing
on a couple of occasions)

What Juro describes sounds like a possible explanation to me,
especially since there was some wind picking up, blowing
toward 2 or 3 o'clock (I'm right-handed) and messing with my
backcasts, and I was trying hard to beat that wind. The wind
on the Oahu is almost a constant nuisance for flyfishers. I may
have developed a bad habit from trying to beat the wind since
I moved here a year ago. I will watch my casting stroke more
carefully from the next time out.

Fishordie

juro
09-19-2006, 04:58 PM
Best thing to do is put the wind on the opposite side from the casting arm so that it's blowing across your body and pushing the line away from you.

That way you actually have to work less because the wind does half the work of loading the rod by increasing tension.

It might mean walking to another spot where you can change the angle.

Any of those big Hawaii bones lately?

fishordie
09-19-2006, 09:49 PM
Thanks, Juro.

There have been some fish that I couldn't stop with a 10wt rod and 20lb tippet. One broke the butt of a 10wt rod. (Yes, it's kind of silly of me to be fishing with an 8wt rod, even though it's the Horizon... I use Helix 9wt about half of the time.) A friend of mine caught a 10-pounder in front of me, and I heard of an estimated 18-pounder (37" long) taken and released. The biggest one I've landed was about 8 to 9 pound so far. When I catch a bonefish, it's usually a 4-pounder or larger. On the other hand, I haven't caught many fish. I get skunked about half of the time. I guess that's the trade-off here - you tend to catch bigger fish, but fewer fish compared to other popular bonefishing locations. Well, but I'm new to bonefishing. So, you may catch MANY BIG bonefish here!

If you are interested in fishing the Oahu, it's probably the best to hire a guide (Nervous Water Flyfishers offer guide services, and I've heard that they are pretty good) If you want to try by yourself, let me know. I will tell you several good spots that I know of.

Fishordie