Long Island, Bahamas [Archive] - Fly Fishing Forum

: Long Island, Bahamas


EricG
04-21-2006, 12:15 AM
I just got back from Deadmanís Cay on Long Island in the Bahamas fly fishing for bonefish with Dwayne Knowles while staying at Greenwich Creek lodge.
We had 5 days to find fish. The weather was not very cooperative. It blew hard day and night and was cloudy and occasionally rainy.
We managed to find fish, often spooking them as we got too close before spotting them. We managed several fish every day with plenty of shots.
Iíve only flats fished one other time in Key West where I didnít get a shot in 3 days of fishing. This was just a bit different.
We had fish chasing our flies with incredible abandon. I witnessed my partner make a cast that landed a foot behind a fish moving away from her. The fly hit the water and the fish spun and ate the fly just like a trout hitting a dry fly. They chased our flies as we stripped them in right up to the boat sometimes eating them and sometimes not. It was incredible. I stood in one spot for almost 3 hours on a flat and had fish continuously swim within casting range. I had numerous shots and occasionally got a fish hooked up. I had several refusals and missed shots due to poor casting.
Rookie mistakes included leaving the boat without flies and tippet. (Would you believe I did it twice? You would if you knew me!)
I read a few times that the fish were small on Long Island. Well, we caught several fish. The 2 smallest Iíd say were 3 lbs. They averaged 4 lbs and the largest were 6+. We saw fish to 10 but didnít get close to them.
Iím glad I spent several hours in the weeks prior to this trip practicing casting. I canít encourage this enough. Not only did it help with endurance but also accuracy and judgment. Despite significant wind at times I was happy with my casting. There were times that I needed to make long casts but most often they were no more than 30 ft and needed to land softly. Sometimes I was able to do this. Practice!
Thanks to all of you who post information on this board. It helped tremendously.
Eric

juro
04-21-2006, 06:09 AM
Awesome report and welcome aboard Eric!

Sorry to hear the weather didn't cooperate but it sounds like you had some real success out there just the same. I can only imagine what you could have done with ideal conditions.

And it sounds like your fishing buddy is a lady too - you are living right my friend. How were the accomodations for her? Many of us are thinking of a 'couples' clave.

thanks

Adrian
04-21-2006, 07:09 AM
Great report Eric, thanks for sharing:smokin:

Early season in the Bahamas can be "iffy" on the weather front but the cooler water on the flats seems to attract the bigger bonefish. Some of the biggest bones of the year are caught during the colder months.

EricG
04-23-2006, 07:59 PM
Juro,
The lodge was quite nice and about 6 years old. It is 2 seperate 2 story buildings. on the bottom floor of one is the dining room, kitchen and bar. above that are four rooms, 2 of them on the water. our rooms were clean and bright. there were 2 f/q beds in each, dresser, small table with chairs and a full bath. the other building has 4 rooms on each floor, 4 on the water. There is a balcony/wrap around porch on each floor allowing for outside sitting/viewing. The food was good. our package included 3 meals a day so we didn't sample any of the local spots. the dining area has a tv/vcr/dvd with cable so you can stay in touch with the outside world if you desire. no broadband internet connection.:frown: didn't try dial up. it has a nice pool in the back.
my wife (didn't go) is into dogs (agility) i tried to get her into flyfishing but it didn't last long. my fishing partner is a friend who gets to fish 100+ days a year.
here is a link to some of the pictures http://www.cardigan-corgis.com/Eric%20in%20Bahamas.htm
it can be booked through bucaneer travel but we found out a better deal can be scored booking direct with the lodge. Dwyane and Samantha Knowles bonefishdwayne@msn.com lodge number is 242.337.6278
Eric